Clergy Religious Beliefs Are Associated With Greater ICU Care in Congregants’ Final Days

Clergy Religious Beliefs Are Associated With Greater ICU Care in Congregants’ Final Days

By Jo Cavallo
For all you doubting Thomas’s out there. I have seen this countless times . When the spirituality of the patient is addressed it acts as a magnet to health care workers. I have seen my one miracle per career  and frankly believing in miracles is miraculous enough. For me , however, and I never was quiet about it , I totally did not support redemptive suffering – shame , guilt and just punishment as the patient or family would go down that road, God is a merciful God and a God of grace and  not knowable by mere mortals. THAT helped hundreds I ushered off this mortal coil. Furthermore, it is not part of fundamental Christian theology that God DOES frequently interfere in the course of a  terminal disease. The world is unfair and not the domain of Jesus. It is not that God cannot- HE can do anything. It is that it is exquisitely rare to see inexplicable , never seen before magical turnarounds in terminal patients. That is the world we live in  but not the world we hope to spend eternity in  Read this critically and consider the source is clergy- a lot of harm can be done by acting out beliefs that do not change outcomes and the clergy is often the source( I am NOT anti clergy)  I am a very well schooled by Jesuit non denominational bible believing Christian…very well schooled theologically

 Key Points:
  • A majority of survey respondents affirmed miracles and sanctity of life in congregants’ theological statements in end-of-life medical decisions. A minority affirmed God is in control and redemptive suffering.
  • Clergy endorsement of theological beliefs was strongly correlated with not having end-of-life discussions with congregants.
  • A lack of clergy-congregant discussion of hospice predicted less hospice utilization and increased ICU care. Clergy endorsement that God is in control was the only theological belief predicting ICU use in the final week of life.  I have seen that as well and it can and usually does cause enormous suffering of the patient , the family and the staff as well as enormous costs. Those who know their Judeo Christian and even Islamic theology understand this

A survey exploring the relationship between spiritual support and end-of-life care by evaluating clergy members’ opinions and experiences related to care provided to congregants at the end of their life has found that a majority of clergy endorse religious beliefs regarding their congregants’ medical care. Eighty-six percent of respondents affirmed belief in a miraculous cure, and 54% agreed that the congregant should accept every medical treatment out of religious obligations.

These beliefs, according to the study findings, are associated with greater intensive care unit (ICU) care in their congregants’ final days. The study (Abstract 223) by Balboni et al was presented during the 2015 Palliative Care in Oncology Symposium in Boston.

Study Methodology

The researchers used data supplied from a survey they conducted as part of the National Clergy Project on End-of-Life Care, a National Cancer Institute–funded study. The study included responses from 1,665 U.S. clergy randomly selected from a database of 368,408 congregations. The survey was conducted via direct mail, telephone, and e-mail. Data collection occurred between August 2014 and March 2015.

The survey recipients were asked to rate their level of affirmation of six statements that assessed theological beliefs influencing medical decisions by patients who were “extremely likely to die in the next 6 months.”

The respondents reported endorsement of religious beliefs about the congregant’s end-of-life care, including miracles, sanctity of life, divine sovereignty, and redemptive suffering. The clergy members reported on their last experience in spiritual caregiving to a dying congregant, including the congregant’s care location in the final week of life. The primary outcome was any ICU care in the final week of life.

Study Results

The survey findings showed that most (86%) respondents affirmed belief in a miraculous cure; 54% agreed that the congregant should accept every medical treatment out of religious obligations. A minority of clergy affirmed that belief in divine sovereignty relieved congregants of future medical decisions (28%) and that they should endure medical procedures because suffering is God’s test (27%).

In multivariable analyses, higher religious beliefs about congregants’ end-of-life care (RBEC) scores were associated with a greater likelihood of any ICU utilization in the last week (adjusted odds ratio [AOR] = 1.28, P =.02), with belief in divine sovereignty being the strongest predictor (AOR = 2.1, P = .005). Predictors of having greater RBEC scores included being Hispanic (AOR = 3.35, P < .001) or black (AOR = 3.0, P < .001) as compared to white, and being Pentecostal (AOR = 3.54, P < .001) or Evangelical (AOR = 2.12, P < .001) as compared to clergy self-identified as liberal.

“A majority of clergy endorse religious beliefs regarding their dying congregants’ [end-of-life] medical care; these beliefs are associated with greater ICU care in the final days of life for congregants. Future research is needed to determine religiously consistent approaches to clergy [end-of-life] education to mitigate aggressive interventions at the [end of life],” concluded the researchersAmen and I have spent thousands of hours in the ICU with hundreds of patients

The study authors reported no conflicts of interest. This study was funded by the National Cancer Institute.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s