Study: Breast cancer detection not better with computer aid

 

Study: Breast cancer detection not better with computer aid

By LINDSEY TANNER AP Medical Writer

 

It is a good thing to see the self policing of steps we take in diagnosis to assess, once we have enough numbers to see if they live up to their original hoped for benefit ,Usually they do but here ,we have an example showing it simply may not be needed- And in the wake  of this   the  is the intense scrutiny other imaging techniques may be superior to mammogram Dr Ryan

CHICAGO (AP) — Computer-assisted detection used in most U.S. mammograms adds no benefit to breast cancer screening while substantially increasing costs, a large study suggests.

Some previous research said computer technology could serve almost as a second set of eyes for doctors. The technique uses special software to highlight suspicious-looking areas on mammogram images that radiologists who interpret the scans may have missed. The doctors then take another look before making a determination.

But some of these earlier studies involved adding computer detection to mammograms using outdated film X-rays, not more advanced digital X-rays now used in most mammograms nationwide, the study authors said. The older technique was more cumbersome; now computer-assisted detection is a standard part of digital mammogram machines.

The study involved nearly 324,000 women who had digital mammograms from 2003 to 2009. The researchers compared cancer detection rates after scans with and without computer-assisted detection. About 20 percent of scans did not include the technology.

The overall cancer detection rate – about 4 in 1,000 women – was similar in both groups.

Computer-assisted scans did prove to be slightly better at detecting very early tumors called ductal carcinoma in situ or DCIS, but whether that is a benefit is debatable because these tumors are not invasive and some experts think they should not even be considered true cancers.  Dr Ryan disagrees

The technology “may be encouraging radiologists to find lesions that don’t matter as much,” said lead author Dr. Constance Lehman, director of breast imaging at Massachusetts General Hospital. “The jury’s still out on whether that’s benefiting these women.”

The study was published Monday in JAMA Internal Medicine. The National Cancer Institute paid for the research.

Screening mammograms are preventive care and many insurers cover the scans with no copay for patients. However it costs the health system more. It was approved for mammograms in 1998, Medicare coverage was added a few years later and private insurers followed suit. Doctors get paid $7 more from Medicare and $20 more from private insurers for mammograms done with computer-assisted technology. We do not , as some decry” Make a killing” Dr Ryan

We need to be really on top of new technology so we’re using our health care dollars wisely and not spending dollars where we don’t see a benefit,” Lehman said.  BOTTOM LINE DR RYAN

An editorial in the journal says the study raises important questions about continued use of the technology with screening mammograms.

“Payments for ineffective services like CAD (computer-aided detection) combine to bloat our health care economy,” the editorial said.

But Dr. Kathryn Evers, director of breast imaging at Fox Chase Cancer Center, said the study “is certainly not the last word.”

CAD devices differ and some may be more effective than others, Evers said, recommending additional research to determine when the technique might be appropriate in breast cancer screening.

Online:

JAMA Internal Medicine: http://jamainternalmedicine.com

Breast cancer screening: http://tinyurl.com/cnnhwy

 

// g?c=a+f+c:(g+=f.length,f=a.indexOf(“&”,g),c=0<=f?a.substring(0,g)+c+a.substring(f):a.substring(0,g)+c)}return 2E3<c.length?void 0!==d?q(a,b,d,void 0,e):a:c};var ca=function(){var a=/[&\?]exk=([^& ]+)/.exec(r.location.href);return a&&2==a.length?a[1]:null};var da=function(a,b,c){a.addEventListener?a.addEventListener(b,c,!1):a.attachEvent&&a.attachEvent(“on”+b,c)};var ea=function(a,b){for(var c in a)Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(a,c)&&b.call(void 0,a[c],c,a)},ga=function(){var a=fa;if(!a)return””;var b=/.*[&#?]google_debug(=[^&]*)?(&.*)?$/;try{var c=b.exec(decodeURIComponent(a));if(c)return c[1]&&1<c[1].length?c[1].substring(1):”true”}catch(d){}return””};var ha=function(a){var b=””;ea(a,function(a,d){if(0===a||a)b+=”&”+d+”=”+encodeURIComponent(String(a))});return b},ia=function(a,b,c){a.google_image_requests||(a.google_image_requests=[]);var d=a.document.createElement(“img”);if(c){var e=function(a){c(a);a=e;d.removeEventListener?d.removeEventListener(“load”,a,!1):d.detachEvent&&d.detachEvent(“onload”,a);a=e;d.removeEventListener?d.removeEventListener(“error”,a,!1):d.detachEvent&&d.detachEvent(“onerror”,a)};da(d,”load”,e);da(d,”error”,e)}d.src=b;a.google_image_requests.push(d)};var ja=function(a,b,c){this.u=a;this.s=b;this.c=c;this.f=null;this.o=this.g;this.w=!1},ka=function(a,b,c){this.message=a;this.fileName=b||””;this.lineNumber=c||-1},ma=function(a,b,c){var d;try{d=c()}catch(g){var e=a.c;try{var f=la(g),e=a.o.call(a,b,f,void 0,void 0)}catch(l){a.g(“pAR”,l)}if(!e)throw g;}finally{}return d},t=function(a,b){var c=na;return function(){var d=arguments;return ma(c,a,function(){return b.apply(void 0,d)})}};ja.prototype.g=function(a,b,c,d,e){var f={};f.context=a;b instanceof ka||(b=la(b));f.msg=b.message.substring(0,512);b.fileName&&(f.file=b.fileName);0<b.lineNumber&&(f.line=b.lineNumber.toString());a=h.document;f.url=a.URL.substring(0,512);f.ref=a.referrer.substring(0,512);if(this.f)try{this.f(f)}catch(l){}if(d)try{d(f)}catch(l){}d=this.u;try{if((this.w?d.v:Math.random())<(c||d.m)){var g=d.l+(e||this.s)+ha(f),g=g.substring(0,2E3);ia(h,g)}}catch(l){}return this.c};var la=function(a){var b=a.toString();a.name&&-1==b.indexOf(a.name)&&(b+=”: “+a.name);a.message&&-1==b.indexOf(a.message)&&(b+=”: “+a.message);if(a.stack){var c=a.stack,d=b;try{-1==c.indexOf(d)&&(c=d+”\n”+c);for(var e;c!=e;)e=c,c=c.replace(/((https?:\/..*\/)[^\/:]*:\d+(?:.|\n)*)\2/,”$1″);b=c.replace(/\n */g,”\n”)}catch(f){b=d}}return new ka(b,a.fileName,a.lineNumber)};var pa=String.prototype.trim?function(a){return a.trim()}:function(a){return a.replace(/^[\s\xa0]+|[\s\xa0]+$/g,””)},qa=function(a,b){return ab?1:0};var u=Array.prototype,ra=u.indexOf?function(a,b,c){return u.indexOf.call(a,b,c)}:function(a,b,c){c=null==c?0:0>c?Math.max(0,a.length+c):c;if(k(a))return k(b)&&1==b.length?a.indexOf(b,c):-1;for(;c<a.length;c++)if(c in a&&a[c]===b)return c;return-1},sa=u.map?function(a,b,c){return u.map.call(a,b,c)}:function(a,b,c){for(var d=a.length,e=Array(d),f=k(a)?a.split(“”):a,g=0;gparseFloat(a))?String(b):a}(),Fa={},Ga=function(a){if(!Fa[a]){for(var b=0,c=pa(String(Ea)).split(“.”),d=pa(String(a)).split(“.”),e=Math.max(c.length,d.length),f=0;0==b&&f<e;f++){var g=c[f]||””,l=d[f]||””,A=RegExp(“(\\d*)(\\D*)”,”g”),oa=RegExp(“(\\d*)(\\D*)”,”g”);do{var m=A.exec(g)||[“”,””,””],K=oa.exec(l)||[“”,””,””];if(0==m[0].length&&0==K[0].length)break;b=qa(0==m[1].length?0:parseInt(m[1],10),0==K[1].length?0:parseInt(K[1],10))||qa(0==m[2].length,0==K[2].length)||qa(m[2],K[2])}while(0==b)}Fa[a]=0<=b}},Ha=h.document,Ia=Ha&&z?Da()||(“CSS1Compat”==Ha.compatMode?parseInt(Ea,10):5):void 0;var Ja;if(!(Ja=!Aa&&!z)){var Ka;if(Ka=z)Ka=9<=Ia;Ja=Ka}Ja||Aa&&Ga(“1.9.1”);z&&Ga(“9”);var B=document,r=window;var C=null;function D(a){return”function”==typeof encodeURIComponent?encodeURIComponent(a):escape(a)}var E=function(a,b){ia(a,b,void 0)},La=function(){if(!B.body)return!1;if(!C){var a=B.createElement(“iframe”);a.style.display=”none”;a.id=”anonIframe”;C=a;B.body.appendChild(a)}return!0},Ma={};var na,Na=”http”+(“http:”==r.location.protocol?””:”s”)+”://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/gen_204?id=”;na=new ja(new function(){this.l=Na;this.m=.01;this.v=Math.random()},”jserror”,!0);var F=function(a,b){return t(a,b)};var Oa=function(a,b,c){if(“array”==aa(b))for(var d=0;d<b.length;d++)Oa(a,String(b[d]),c);else null!=b&&c.push(“&”,a,””===b?””:”=”,encodeURIComponent(String(b)))},Pa=function(a,b,c){for(c=c||0;c<b.length;c+=2)Oa(b[c],b[c+1],a);return a},Qa=function(a,b){var c=2==arguments.length?Pa([a],arguments[1],0):Pa([a],arguments,1);if(c[1]){var d=c[0],e=d.indexOf(“#”);0e?c[1]=”?”:e==d.length-1&&(c[1]=void 0)}return c.join(“”)};var Ra={j:”ud=1″,i:”ts=0″,A:”sc=1″,h:”gz=1″};if(B&&B.URL){var fa=B.URL,Sa=!(fa&&0=b)){var d=0,e=function(){a();d++;db;){if(c.google_osd_static_frame)return c;if(c.aswift_0&&(!a||c.aswift_0.google_osd_static_frame))return c.aswift_0;b++;c=c!=c.parent?c.parent:null}}catch(d){}return null},Xa=function(a,b,c,d,e){if(10<Va)r.clearInterval(M);else if(++Va,r.postMessage&&(b.b||b.a)){var f=Wa(!0);if(f){var g={};I(b,g);g[0]=”goog_request_monitoring”;g[6]=a;g[16]=c;d&&d.length&&(g[17]=d.join(“,”));e&&(g[19]=e);try{var l=L(g);f.postMessage(l,”*”)}catch(A){}}}},Ya=function(a){var b=Wa(!1),c=!b;!b&&r&&(b=r.parent);if(b&&b.postMessage)try{b.postMessage(a,”*”),c&&r.postMessage(a,”*”)}catch(d){}};var N=!1,O=function(a){if(a=a.match(/[\d]+/g))a.length=3};if(navigator.plugins&&navigator.plugins.length){var Za=navigator.plugins[“Shockwave Flash”];Za&&(N=!0,Za.description&&O(Za.description));navigator.plugins[“Shockwave Flash 2.0”]&&(N=!0)}else if(navigator.mimeTypes&&navigator.mimeTypes.length){var $a=navigator.mimeTypes[“application/x-shockwave-flash”];(N=$a&&$a.enabledPlugin)&&O($a.enabledPlugin.description)}else try{var P=new ActiveXObject(“ShockwaveFlash.ShockwaveFlash.7”),N=!0;O(P.GetVariable(“$version”))}catch(a){try{P=new ActiveXObject(“ShockwaveFlash.ShockwaveFlash.6”),N=!0}catch(b){try{P=new ActiveXObject(“ShockwaveFlash.ShockwaveFlash”),N=!0,O(P.GetVariable(“$version”))}catch(c){}}};var ab=x(“Firefox”),bb=xa()||x(“iPod”),cb=x(“iPad”),db=x(“Android”)&&!(wa()||x(“Firefox”)||y()||x(“Silk”)),eb=wa(),fb=x(“Safari”)&&!(wa()||x(“Coast”)||y()||x(“Edge”)||x(“Silk”)||x(“Android”))&&!(xa()||x(“iPad”)||x(“iPod”));var Q=function(a){return(a=a.exec(w))?a[1]:””};(function(){if(ab)return Q(/Firefox\/([0-9.]+)/);if(z||ya)return Ea;if(eb)return Q(/Chrome\/([0-9.]+)/);if(fb&&!(xa()||x(“iPad”)||x(“iPod”)))return Q(/Version\/([0-9.]+)/);if(bb||cb){var a;if(a=/Version\/(\S+).*Mobile\/(\S+)/.exec(w))return a[1]+”.”+a[2]}else if(db)return(a=Q(/Android\s+([0-9.]+)/))?a:Q(/Version\/([0-9.]+)/);return””})();var hb=function(){var a=r.parent&&r.parent!=r,b=a&&0<=”//tpc.googlesyndication.com”.indexOf(r.location.host);if(a&&r.name&&0==r.name.indexOf(“google_ads_iframe”)||b){var c;a=r||r;try{var d;if(a.document&&!a.document.body)d=new v(-1,-1);else{var e=(a||window).document,f=”CSS1Compat”==e.compatMode?e.documentElement:e.body;d=(new v(f.clientWidth,f.clientHeight)).round()}c=d}catch(g){c=new v(-12245933,-12245933)}return gb(c)}c=r.document.getElementsByTagName(“SCRIPT”);return 0<c.length&&(c=c[c.length-1],c.parentElement&&c.parentElement.id&&0<c.parentElement.id.indexOf(“_ad_container”))?gb(void 0,c.parentElement):null},gb=function(a,b){var c=ib(“IMG”,a,b);return c||(c=ib(“IFRAME”,a,b))?c:(c=ib(“OBJECT”,a,b))?c:null},ib=function(a,b,c){var d=document;c=c||d;d=a&&”*”!=a?a.toUpperCase():””;c=c.querySelectorAll&&c.querySelector&&d?c.querySelectorAll(d+””):c.getElementsByTagName(d||”*”);for(d=0;d<c.length;d++){var e=c[d];if(“OBJECT”==a)a:{var f=e.getAttribute(“height”);if(null!=f&&0<f&&0==e.clientHeight)for(var f=e.children,g=0;g<f.length;g++){var l=f[g];if(“OBJECT”==l.nodeName||”EMBED”==l.nodeName){e=l;break a}}}f=e.clientHeight;g=e.clientWidth;if(l=b)l=new v(g,f),l=Math.abs(b.width-l.width)<.1*b.width&&Math.abs(b.height-l.height)<.1*b.height;if(l||!b&&10<f&&10<g)return e}return null};var jb,R=0,S=””,T=!1,U=!1,V=!1,kb=!0,lb=!1,mb=!1,nb=!1,ob=!1,pb=””,qb=0,rb=0,W=0,sb=[],J=null,tb=””,ub=[],vb=null,wb=[],xb=!1,yb=””,zb=””,Ab=(new Date).getTime(),Bb=!1,Cb=””,Db=!1,Eb=[“1″,”0″,”3″],X=0,Y=0,Fb=0,Gb=””,Ib=function(a,b,c){T&&(kb||3!=(c||3)||mb)&&Hb(a,b,!0);if(V||U&&lb)Hb(a,b),U=V=!1},Jb=function(){var a=vb;return a?2!=a():!0},Hb=function(a,b,c){(b=b||tb)&&!xb&&(2==Y||c)&&Jb()&&(b=Kb(b,c),E(a,b),ob=!0,c?T=!1:xb=!0)},Kb=function(a,b){var c;c=b?”osdim”:V?”osd2″:”osdtos”;var d=[“//pagead2.googlesyndication.com/activeview”,”?id=”,c];”osd2″==c&&U&&lb&&d.push(“&ts=1”);S&&d.push(“&avi=”,S);jb&&d.push(“&cid=”,jb);d.push(“&ti=1”);d.push(“&”,a);d.push(“&uc=”+Fb);Bb?d.push(“&tgt=”+Cb):d.push(“&tgt=nf”);d.push(“&cl=”+(Db?1:0));””!=pb&&(d.push(“&lop=1”),c=n()-qb,d.push(“&tslp=”+c));d=d.join(“”);for(c=0;c<ub.length;c++){try{var e=ub[c]()}catch(g){}var f=”max_length”;2<=e.length&&(3==e.length&&(f=e[2]),d=q(d,D(e[0]),D(e[1]),f))}2E3<d.length&&(d=d.substring(0,2E3));return d},Z=function(a,b){if(yb){try{var c=q(yb,”vi”,a);La()&&E(C.contentWindow,c)}catch(e){}0<=ra(Eb,a)&&(yb=””);var c=b||tb,d;d=q(“//pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/gen_204?id=sldb”,”avi”,S);d=q(d,”vi”,a);c&&(d+=”&”+c);try{E(r,d)}catch(e){}}},Lb=function(){Z(“-1”)},Nb=function(a){if(a&&a.data&&k(a.data)){var b;var c=a.data;if(k(c)){b={};for(var c=c.split(“\n”),d=0;d=e)){var f=Number(c[d].substr(0,e)),e=c[d].substr(e+1);switch(f){case 5:case 8:case 11:case 15:case 16:case 18:e=”true”==e;break;case 4:case 7:case 6:case 14:case 20:case 21:case 22:case 23:e=Number(e);break;case 3:case 19:if(“function”==aa(decodeURIComponent))try{e=decodeURIComponent(e)}catch(l){throw Error(“Error: URI malformed: “+e);}break;case 17:e=sa(decodeURIComponent(e).split(“,”),Number)}b[f]=e}}b=b[0]?b:null}else b=null;if(b&&(c=new H(b[4],b[12]),J&&J.match(c))){for(c=0;cX&&!U&&2==Y&&Ob(r,”osd2″,”hs=”+X)},Qb=function(){var a={};I(J,a);a[0]=”goog_dom_content_loaded”;var b=L(a);try{Ta(function(){Ya(b)},10,”osd_listener::ldcl_int”)}catch(c){}},Rb=function(){var a={};I(J,a);a[0]=”goog_creative_loaded”;var b=L(a);Ta(function(){Ya(b)},10,”osd_listener::lcel_int”);Db=!0},Sb=function(a){if(k(a)){a=a.split(“&”);for(var b=a.length-1;0<=b;b–){var c=a[b],d=Ra;c==d.j?(kb=!1,a.splice(b,1)):c==d.h?(W=1,a.splice(b,1)):c==d.i&&(U=!1,a.splice(b,1))}Gb=a.join(“&”)}},Tb=function(){if(!Bb){var a=hb();a&&(Bb=!0,Cb=a.tagName,a.complete||a.naturalWidth?Rb():G(a,”load”,Rb,”osd_listener::creative_load”))}};p(“osdlfm”,F(“osd_listener::init”,function(a,b,c,d,e,f,g,l,A,oa){R=a;yb=b;zb=d;T=f;jb=oa;l&&Sb(l);U=f;1==A?sb.push(947190538):2==A?sb.push(947190541):3==A&&sb.push(947190542);J=new H(e,ca());G(r,”load”,Lb,”osd_listener::load”);G(r,”message”,Nb,”osd_listener::message”);S=c||””;G(r,”unload”,Pb,”osd_listener::unload”);var m=r.document;!m.readyState||”complete”!=m.readyState&&”loaded”!=m.readyState?(“msie”in Ma?Ma.msie:Ma.msie=-1!=navigator.userAgent.toLowerCase().indexOf(“msie”))&&!window.opera?G(m,”readystatechange”,function(){“complete”!=m.readyState&&”loaded”!=m.readyState||Qb()},”osd_listener::rsc”):G(m,”DOMContentLoaded”,Qb,”osd_listener::dcl”):Qb();-1==R?Y=f?3:1:-2==R?Y=3:0

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s